Alibaba fell more than 5 per cent and Tencent dropped as much as 4.4 per cent in Hong Kong trading on Thursday, tracking losses in their New York-listed securities. The State Department, Department of Defense and Treasury Department are among authorities involved in the deliberations, according to people with knowledge of the talks. The discussions focus in part on how such a move might affect capital markets, the Wall Street Journal reported earlier Wednesday.
Imposing a ban on the two companies would mark the most dramatic escalation yet by President Donald Trumpâs administration, given the sheer size of the two firms and the difficulty unwinding positions. At $ 1.3 trillion, the combined market value of their primary listings is nearly twice the size of Spainâs stock market, while the firms together account for about 11 per cent of the weighting for MSCI Inc.âs emerging markets benchmark.
âIf the bans are implemented then itâd be a huge thing for the market,â said Steven Leung, executive director at Uob Kay Hian (Hong Kong) Ltd. âItâs still too early to say. After the Biden administration starts, the policy could change again.â
If implemented, the ban would further fray the relationship between the worldâs two largest economies, which have clashed over everything from Covid-19 to Hong Kong. Authorities in Washington have been ramping up efforts to deprive Chinese companies of U.S. capital in the final months of the Trump administration, adding to economic tensions as President-elect Joe Biden prepares to take over this month.
Representatives for the companies had no immediate comment when contacted. Spreads on Tencentâs dollar bonds widened as much as 20 basis points over Treasuries on Thursday, while those on Alibaba notes were about 15 basis points wider, according to credit traders. The e-commerce company was said to be planning a dollar bond sale that could raise as much as $ 8 billion as early as next week, which could now be threatened by the U.S. actions. What Bloomberg Intelligence Says:
Alibaba may face minimal financial and operational disruptions from a potential ban considered by U.S. officials, which could prohibit Americans from investing in the company. Alibaba had $ 60 billion cash as of September, and generated $ 6 billion in free cash flow in the September quarter. The dual listing of its shares in Hong Kong should mitigate any risk of removal from U.S. exchanges.
— Vey-Sern Ling and Tiffany Tam, analysts
JD.com Inc. sank 4.1 per cent in Hong Kong, following a 7.7 per cent drop in its ADRs. Pinduoduo Inc. tumbled 5.6 per cent. The closely-watched iShares China Large-Cap ETF fell 1.2 per cent in the U.S. while the NASDAQ Golden Dragon China Index, which tracks other large Chinese technology stocks, dropped 2.1 per cent for its worst day since November.
Citing national security, Trump previously signed an executive order in November requiring investors to pull out of Chinese companies linked to that nationâs military. On Tuesday, Trump signed an order banning U.S. transactions with eight Chinese apps including Ant Group Co.âs Alipay and Tencentâs digital wallets. It will be up to Biden to decide whether to enforce that policy once it takes effect.
Hasty measures have at times sown confusion in markets and prompted price swings, such as when the New York Stock Exchange reversed course twice this week on a decision to delist three Chinese telecommunications companies. The NYSE is now proceeding with its original delisting plan after U.S. Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin disagreed with its decision to give the firms a reprieve.
The order bans trading in the affected securities starting Jan. 11. If Biden leaves Trumpâs executive order in place, U.S. investment firms and pension funds would be required to sell their holdings in companies linked to the Chinese military by Nov. 11. And if the U.S. determines additional companies have military ties in the future, American investors will be given 60 days from that determination to divest.
âWeâre seeing with the telecommunications companies and with the ADRs the kind of worst-case scenario because you have a tremendous amount of confusion,â said Nicholas Turner, a lawyer at Steptoe & Johnson LLP in Hong Kong who specializes in economic sanctions. Even if Alibaba and Tencent fend off a delisting threat, U.S. investors will still be prohibited from purchasing a wide variety of financial instruments exposed to their securities, he added.
The potential U.S. ban comes as pressures mount within China on Jack Maâs Alibaba and Tencent. In recent months, officials blocked Ant Groupâs $ 35 billion IPO, proposed new rules to curb the dominance of internet giants and fined Alibaba and Tencent over acquisitions from years before. Closer scrutiny of mergers and acquisitions could add uncertainty over the growth of large internet firms within China.